Why is Mark of the Doubting Knight worth so little?

"

grant_m написал:

This item illustrates the one trick pony nature of PoE when it comes to damage scaling/survivability for melee play. You have 1 choice. Attack speed.

I'd say the bigger issue is that it's a dagger with no +crit. I could work it into my build despite the slower attack speed if it had good crit and good damage. I'm actively looking for dagger upgrades right now.

With daggers, I basically rate them on a four star scale. +crit will earn up to two stars depending on how high, high attack speed can earn one, and high base damage for one. This dagger gets a one or maybe one and a half star review. It's damage is fine, but the 7.2% crit is worth max of a half star, and has slow attack speed. Not utter trash on its face, but given its high level requirement people will be looking for at least a two and probably a three+ star dagger at that point.

If I get around to making a dual-wield-block version of this build, it might fill a gap as an off-hand for the +5% block and +res, but only as a stepping stone to something better.

I think because - "you are playing in beyond league". That dagger isnt very HC viable.

Sorry for necro posting but.. instead of adding tons of new uniquest to PoE the devs should revise all that crap uniques like this dagger...

"

Garfunkel написал:

Sorry for necro posting but.. instead of adding tons of new uniquest to PoE the devs should revise all that crap uniques like this dagger...

they do

Lots of things GGG can do to make this item worthwhile - maybe in a future revision. All in all there are way too many useless uniques dropping and there will be more to come. I'd prefer MUCH LESS uniques dropping as long as when one dropped it was excellent. I guess "unique" means something different than what I think it means.

if it had like 9-11 base crit, it would be interesting with the new assassin subclass

Holy molly double necro...

This post first ended on 9/19/2014

Then someone necro'ed it on 7/21/2015

Then someone necro'ed it again on 1/30/2016

PoE is not a new game already, hopefully people will one day understand that 90% of the uniques in PoE are trash, 9% are useful, and the last 1% are stupidly OP.

Also a lot of uniques don't make sense because a lot of supporters tailor their unique to fit w/e spec they are playing at the time which is probably no longer viable now... and sometimes GGG intend to have some drawbacks so not all uniques are the best.

"

Pewzor написал:

Holy molly double necro...

This post first ended on 9/19/2014

Then someone necro'ed it on 7/21/2015

Then someone necro'ed it again on 1/30/2016

PoE is not a new game already, hopefully people will one day understand that 90% of the uniques in PoE are trash, 9% are useful, and the last 1% are stupidly OP.

Also a lot of uniques don't make sense because a lot of supporters tailor their unique to fit w/e spec they are playing at the time which is probably no longer viable now... and sometimes GGG intend to have some drawbacks so not all uniques are the best.

90 % = trash?

Because Mathil/ZiggyD hasn't made a build using it yet

Mediocre phys, 7% crit and extremaly low attack speed. If it was "you always apply bleed and poison with crit" it would be very good weapon, now its kinda crappy.